Recently I was asked, Is a theory, a "truth," or just a more truthful picture? My response?
Answering this question requires we leave the realm of physics and venture into the realm of the philosopher. You see, the word "truth" is in fact more a philosophical state than a literal physical fact.
So why do most folks see these two things as the same? Or at least as the truth and the proof of truth? I'd guess, because, we ourselves are physical beings whose consciousness is based in light. We literally know things because we see pictures. Thus, we have a hard time believing in the things we cannot picture.
Conversely, we can believe a whole lot of false things just because we can picture them. For instance, believing the world is flat and held up by four turtles. Or by an Arnold Schwarzeneggar type character. Obviously, today, we know these things to be untrue. However, because they could easily be pictured, we once mistook them as true.
This, in fact, is what makes the famous picture of the Earth as seen from one of the early satellites so important to our sense of truth. We finally could see with our own eyes that the Earth is round. And blue.
As for "theory," what might help here would be to know where this word comes from. Years ago, a young doctor taught me that in ancient Greece, medical doctors studied in amphitheaters. Something like the operating theaters in which modern medical students learn.
Similar to what we do now then, in ancient Greece, the doctors "in a teaching hospital" operated on the patient in the center of the amphitheater, down on the ground level. Then the more experienced doctors sat in the seats and observed. In fact, where in the seats these doctors sat was determined by their level of experience. The more their experience, the higher they sat. Which meant the most experienced doctors had the greatest overview, as they sat in the highest seats.
The word "theory" comes from what they called these seats. They called these seats, the "theoria." Which, in Emergence Personality Theory, relates directly to what is contained in Layer 2 of personality; explanations, excuses, and "logical" why's.
Can you now see what theories are? In effect, they are what you see of life as seen from the highest seats, far from the blood and suffering of the world but with the greatest potential for generalized insights. Which is just another way to say, they offer us the greatest potential for developing explanations, excuses, and logical reasons for whatever happens in our world.
By the way, can you now see what makes me so like Jacob Needleman's "theater of the mind" metaphor?
To see what else I had to say on the nature of theories, click here.







